First belonging to Terra, he bestows it upon Ventus as he discusses his dream of being a Keyblade master. Ventus later made his way to Radiant Garden, fooling around with the toy Keyblade while contemplating a means of saving Terra from the darkness. Lea later approaches him, taking the Wooden Keyblade in his own hands before continuing a conversation between him, Ventus, and Isa, as well as battling Ventus. While exploring Neverland, Ventus leaves it in a treasure chest along with several wooden swords, Aqua later discovering the same chest. Vanitas subsequently steals the Wooden Keyblade and confronts Aqua, telling her that Ventus has "outgrown" the toy before casually snapping the toy weapon in half, an act of cruelty that both horrifies and enrages Aqua greatly. However, after defeating Vanitas, Aqua assures Peter Pan that it was all right when he shows concern over it, reassuring him that their friendship could not be broken so easily.
The Wooden Keyblade has an uncanny resemblance to the Earthshaker and the Kingdom Key, though it is missing a Keychain. Terra's name is carved into the hilt. Made completely from wood, the handle is a dark brown in coloration, same for the tip. Teeth are placed unevenly on both sides (somewhat similarly to the Ends of the Earth), held together by rope, same as the hilt.